I blinked twice and Looked around at the other girls, suddenly worried

I was going to get jealous Looks from the ones I'd already slept with

But Sam, Naimh, and Belle were just smirking at my discomfort. On sudden impulse, I reached out and drew Mari into my lap, brushed her hair back from her face and leaned in to give her a tender kiss. Our lips rubbed together for only a few seconds, and as I pulled back she felt my erection trapped between us and grinded herself down against it.

I grinned and nuzzled her nose. "Whenever you're ready, I will be too."

Mari gave me a relieved smile.

“Thank you. I'm glad." She then blushed while sliding back into her own seat, and around us Sam, Belle, and

Naimh started hooting and cheering.

I leaned back to allow myself a moment of contentment as my three lovers enthusiastically encouraged their virginal friend to join them, when out of the corner of my eye I saw my best friend's hand come down to slap the surface of the water, splashing a surprised Zofi. We all turned to Alice, her face a mutinous mask of hurt and angry emotions.

“Well I'm glad everyone's singing Matty's praises and you're now quite literally queueing up to be his next conquest," Alice bit out through frustrated tears as she elevated herself out of the tub and sat down on the deck. Water streamed down off her naked body, cascading Like waterfalls over her exposed naked breasts. Shaking her head and frowning at Mari, she continued, "I thought at least ONE other girl here had enough sense to realize we're opening a can of worms and this whole thing is gonna turn out to be a trainwreck that destroys everything we've built together. But I guess it's just me. Have fun being Matty's Harem, everyone. I think it's time I went home."

“Alice!" Naimh called out in alarm as the Korean girl spun around, got up, and marched back into the house.

Heaven help me, I couldn't stop myself from ogling Alice's puffy pink pussy from behind when she'd bent over, but I quickly brushed that idea away and called after my grade school buddy, “Alice! Come on! We didn't--"

Naimh was already getting out of the tub as well, and I momentarily caught myself ogling HER gorgeous figure with water running in rivers down all of her curves. Only after she was out did I finally haul myself out, grab a towel, and follow after.

This was NOT good.

Alice was crying in the armchair when I walked in, wrapped in a towel but still pretty wet. Naimh was kneeling on the floor in front of her, clutching another towel around her midsection but the back had come loose and the terrycloth draped to either side of her, leaving her completely exposed from behind. But this wasn't a moment to get sidetracked.

The girls took one look at me as I came in, and Alice immediately held up a hand, saying, “Go away, Matty.”

"Please," I said gently, holding up both hands.

“I'm not here to make you feel worse, but I DO want to do whatever I can to make things better.”

Alice clenched her jaw and looked up at the ceiling for a moment. "I should be really mad at both of you for crossing the line and screwing right here on the couch. YOU, I get it." She pointed an accusatory finger straight at me.

“You've spent years gleefully accepting whatever we girls would let you have. It's never been a question of whether or not you'd say yes if one of us wanted to fuck you. We've always known the answer."

I didn't really know what to say to that, so I stayed silent. But I did at least approach and sit down on the couch cushion closest to her.

Alice turned her ire to Naimh. "YOU, on the other hand. You KNEW I didn't want the group crossing this line.”

"I know, but that line has already BEEN crossed," Naimh argued.

“That doesn't make it right! You were supposed to be on my side. But what did YOU do when you found out Sam and Belle seduced him behind our backs? You immediately forgave them so you could finally fuck him on the spot! What the fuck, Neevie? Let Sam and Belle be the skanks that betrayed the BTC. Not you too!"

"I forgave them because they're our friends."

“They're bitches is what they are. And I can't believe you're defending them! How the fuck does Sam ALWAYS get her fucking way even when she's quite Literally the fucking bitch that stabbed us all in the back?!?