I wanted to fuck Zofi. But at the same time, I had staked my entire reputation with these girls on my dependability to never take advantage of them when their defenses were down. I still remembered Zofi reassuring me I'd made the right decision in not deflowering Alice during the drunken orgy at the end of winter break, and I wouldn't betray her trust today either.
Maybe one day she'd be ready. Until then, I could afford to be patient.
As exciting as it was to see such gorgeous creatures as Naimh and Zofi scissoring, the act did not directly lead into another round of sex.
See, after the two girls managed to bring each other to new orgasms by grinding their clits together, Zofi checked the clock and realized the game had already started.
She asked me to turn it on, and the next thing I knew, I sat naked on the couch watching football while Zofi stroked my dick in her left hand and I fondled her spectacular body in return.
Naimh was... less enthused. "I still don't get why Americans call this
‘football’. The ball rarely ever touches somebody's foot.”
Five minutes later, my Irish girlfriend decided she'd rather kneel in front of me and play with my dick instead of watch the game. I admit it was quite a surreal experience to be getting a blowjob from a gorgeous naked redhead with a gorgeous naked brunette cuddled against my side while watching a football game. That said, the game was a boring, low-scoring affair, and eventually neither Zofi nor I had further interest in it either, not with hot naked teenagers to continue playing with. We'd catch the highlights later.
At that point, the girls decided we'd be more comfortable in my bedroom, so we gathered our clothes and went upstairs. I decided it was past time that I returned the oral favors and started going down on
Naimh (figuring that my "real" girlfriend deserved to go first). But after only a couple of minutes, she said that Zofi had already eaten her to an orgasm and that she hadn't invited Zofi to join us just to be a spectator, so I switched over to the brunette instead. Of course, a minute later, Zofi invited Naimh to sit on her face, so the redhead wound up getting eaten out after all.
The three of us tried out several other positions. I lay on my back with Naimh riding my cock cowgirl while Zofi sat on my face so the two could make out and paw at each other's breasts. Zofi reclined against my headboard with Naimh's head in her crotch and me fucking Naimh from behind. I even fucked Naimh face-to-face while we lay on our sides, our legs scissored together and Naimh grinding her clit against my pelvic bone. Naimh said brightly that I was effectively tribbing with her, and meanwhile Zofi completed the sandwich by spooning herself behind Naimh, nibbling on the redhead's neck and reaching around to squeeze and play with Naimh's nipples.
Naimh felt bad that she was the only one getting fucked, and once asked
Zofi if the brunette was SURE she wasn't ready to have ‘real sex’. "I brought you here to share ‘our' boyfriend after all," she reasoned.
“Don't worry about me." Zofi laughed.
“The way I see it, Matty is sharing his girlfriend with ME."
So with that in mind, Zofi and I teamed up to try and maximize Naimh's pleasure.
I fucked Naimh missionary style while Zofi kissed her upside-down and tweaked the redhead's nipples. The girls then parked themselves face-to-face on their sides so they could make out more comfortably while I spooned my girlfriend and Long-dicked her from behind. And then we rolled over so that Zofi was flat on her back, Naimh was right on top of her with their big tits crushed together, and I continued sawing my cock in and out of Naimh doggy-style.
“Mmm, I wanna eat you again," Zofi then breathed, her blue eyes glittering.
“I wanna wrap my lips around your clitty and suck on that little nub while watching Matty's big dick pulsing deep inside your cunt from up close."
Naimh Laughed. "Works for me."
We paused so Zofi could re-position herself in a sixty-nine. Naimh actually started going down on her first, making the brunette squeak and get distracted, but after gasping and moaning for a minute, Zofi finally grabbed Naimh's ass and brought it down a little Lower so she could start tonguing the redhead's clit.
Every now and again, she'd lick my cock, too. Twice, she had me pull out of Naimh's pussy entirely and tugged my dick down so she could suck on as much of my schlong as she could fit into her mouth before feeding me back inside my girlfriend's cunt.
The position was fun, but the mental high was even better. Just the idea of fucking my “two girlfriends” while they sixty-nined - switching back and forth from one girlfriend's pussy to the other girlfriend's mouth - was incredibly arousing, and I told myself I could really get used to this. But when I sped up and started pumping Naimh's pussy a little harder, Zofi abruptly pushed Naimh's crotch up and started
Laughing.
“What?" Naimh called, picking her head up.