Chapter One Hundred and Twenty-Six

Matteo struggled to suppress a growl as the guard escorting him down the narrow corridor roughly shoved him forward, urging him to pick up the pace. He rolled his eyes in silent frustration but quickened his steps as much as the heavy shackles clamped around his ankles would permit. Behind him, he could hear Frankie’s grumbles and muttered curses, the sound of spit hitting the floor, and the occasional sharp snap of a fist striking out at the guards trying to herd them along. Matteo understood the source of Frankie’s anger—it was stoked deliberately, ignited at every opportunity to provoke a response.

True to their word, the FBI agents were waiting for them on the tarmac. While Matteo managed to keep his temper in check for the sake of appearances and diplomacy, Frankie made no such effort. Seizing the moment, Frankie landed a solid punch on Noah Bennett’s face, aiming to shatter his jaw. Fortunately, Roman had anticipated Frankie’s explosive reaction, as any competent lawyer would. He stepped in swiftly, defusing the tension and ensuring both Matteo and Frankie were handcuffed and loaded into the waiting van without further incident.

Upon arrival at the detention center, the process dragged on for hours. They were read their rights, fingerprinted, photographed, and assigned court dates that, in all likelihood, would never come to pass. The only bright spot in the entire ordeal was the chance to make a phone call. Hearing Gen’s voice on the other end—her concern, her desperate hope for her mafia boss husband’s safety—gave Matteo a flicker of strength to endure whatever lay ahead. After hanging up with her, Frankie tried to call his parents, but they refused to answer. Matteo noticed the pained expression flicker across his friend’s face but chose not to comment as Frankie quietly ended the call, muttering something about them not being home.

Once through the intake procedures, they were stripped down. Matteo had only one request: to keep his wedding ring on his finger. When the guards insisted it had to come off, he refused. That defiance earned him a sharp punch to the face and a forceful removal of the ring. He would never forget the man who yanked that ring from his hand—tainting the last touch of the one person who truly mattered: his wife.

Matteo vowed that once he was free, the first place he’d visit would be that guard’s home. He imagined removing the man’s own wedding ring, perhaps taking Gen’s suggestion to use a cigar cutter, maybe even forcing the guard’s wife to eat the symbol of their bond. Though those dark thoughts softened when his ring was returned to him, they never completely faded.

After that, the indignities continued: a thorough strip search, a humiliating body cavity search, and an unnecessary delousing. They were both dressed in standard orange jumpsuits and velcro shoes, accessorized with the ever-present shackles. Each guard’s sneers and rough treatment etched themselves into Matteo’s memory, destined to linger until cold, unfeeling faces replaced them over time.

“Your room is right up here, Princess,” the guard sneered, dragging Matteo to a stop by the shoulder and yanking him sideways to face an open door. “Room 114. Our presidential suite. Hope it suits your tastes.”

Matteo glanced inside the cramped six-by-eight-foot cell: a narrow bed, a small table bolted to the wall, and a combined sink and toilet unit. “Homey,” he muttered under his breath just before the guard unlocked his restraints and shoved him inside.

Calmly rubbing his wrists, Matteo stood as the heavy door slammed shut behind him, the sound of multiple locks clicking into place echoing in the small space. Through the tiny window, the guard grinned triumphantly.

“Never thought you’d see the inside of one of these, huh, Playboy?” the guard taunted.

“Sir,” Matteo began smoothly, “you seem to have an awful lot of pet names for a small-time thug like me. I should inform you I’m happily married. Perhaps my associate, Mr. Donati, would be more receptive to your advances.”

From the cell next door, Frankie’s sharp laugh rang out. “That ugly pig face? Hell no. I’d never get it up for him. Greek God out here, though… You had me sporting a half chub since those girly hands fondled my balls earlier.” He made exaggerated kissing noises before Matteo heard a thud and Frankie calling after the “Greek god” as the door slammed shut.

“They don’t seem to have much of a sense of humor,” Matteo remarked loud enough for Frankie to catch.

“No, they don’t,” came the reply.

“Such a shame. I was hoping for some entertainment.”

“I’ll be plenty of fun once we get a chance to sit down in the mess hall,” Frankie promised.

“Is that when you plan to start your investigation?” Matteo asked, pacing the small confines of his cell.

“If that’s the earliest opportunity I get,” Frankie replied.

Matteo could hear him moving around, shuffling things and throwing objects against the walls.

“Aha!” Frankie suddenly exclaimed.

“What now?” Matteo sighed, already guessing his friend had discovered something.

“The mattress.”

“What about it?” Matteo glanced at his own stained mattress, the yellow and red blotches evidence of previous occupants’ misdeeds. He resisted the urge to gag and quickly covered it with his blanket.

“There are springs!” Frankie announced triumphantly.

“Well, that’s a relief. Looks like we’ll get a decent night’s sleep after all,” Matteo muttered under his breath.

“What was that?”

“Nothing, Frank,” Matteo said with a weary sigh. “Say, we never really talked about what happened.”

“What happened?” Frankie repeated, cautious.

Matteo walked over to the small window and tried to peer out. “With Stephen.” Silence settled between them for a moment. “Frank.”

“I’m not talking about it, man,” Frankie warned sharply.

“It wasn’t your fault,” Matteo insisted.

“Right,” Frankie snapped, the sound of fabric tearing accompanying his words. “It’s not my fault I left him outside a safehouse with a woman inside wanted by some guy called the Butcher. Not my fault I fled the country. Not my fault my brother’s head was split open and his hands pinned to the side of the house like he was Jesus Christ himself. No, you’re right, Accardi.”

Matteo sighed deeply. “You’re going to find her.”

“You bet I am!” Frankie shouted.

“You’ll make him pay.”

“Pay?” Frankie echoed, now pacing near the door. His laughter echoed down the hall. “Pay? No, Matteo. I won’t make him pay. Not at first. First, I’ll hunt the bastard down because he knows the minute I’m out of this cell, I’m coming for him. Then when I find him, I’m going to toy with him a little—some light stalking. Move a few things around his house, park his car in different spots, make him think he’s losing his mind, but nothing too obvious. Then I’ll start taking out his associates one by one. I’ll crucify them just like they did Stephen. I’ll make him see his loved ones suffer the same way. I’ll fuck his girl. Use her until she tells me she loves me, and then I’ll make sure he knows it. When there’s no one left, I’ll show him the heart she gave me—presented in a box, gift-wrapped for his enjoyment. Then I’ll kill him. Bury their fucking hearts together.”

“You’re not going to kill her,” Matteo said quietly, exhaling.

“Do you doubt my ability?” Frankie shot back.

“I doubt you could kill the girl,” Matteo replied firmly.

Frankie scoffed. “She means nothing!”

“Then why didn’t you tell me about her? Why take her to a safehouse? Why have your brother watching over her?”

“Shut the fuck up!”

“Why fight it?”

“Look at you!” Frankie yelled. “Locked up because you got blinded by some good pussy! That won’t be me.”

Matteo chuckled softly. “Frank… you’re here with me.”

There was a pause. “Because of my brother.”

“Then why the rush? Your brother’s dead. There’s no bringing him back. Trust me, I’ve been where you are. I know what you’re thinking. You’re here because of the girl. You want to save her.”

“I want to make her pay!”

“For what? Capturing your interest? Falling in love with you?”

“Yes.”

“Frankie…” Matteo sighed deeply.

“Just… leave me the fuck alone. I… have work to do,” Frankie said, his voice fading as he retreated further into his cell.

Matteo pressed his forehead against the glass, exhaling a long, weary breath as the heavy silence settled once more.