Chapter Forty-Five

Genevieve could sense the exact moment he stepped into the private box. She had always despised that cliché—how could anyone truly feel another’s presence so deeply that they could pinpoint their arrival? It seemed utterly ridiculous to her. That’s why she stubbornly refused to admit when she felt him enter the room. No, the truth was, she only noticed because everyone else did. The entire group gathered around the perfectly maintained racetrack had paused their chatter, their eyes fixed on the mysterious man who had just arrived. Even as she felt Matteo’s intense gaze cutting across the room, sweeping over her from head to toe, she deliberately avoided meeting his eyes.

Instead, Genevieve focused on the cluster of women who had surrounded her. To her right stood Maisy, her fiery red hair styled into an immaculate updo that complemented her round, cheerful face. The moment Leo had dropped Genevieve off in the box, Maisy had grabbed her arm and whisked her through the room, gathering women as if assembling a small army. After a few introductions, Genevieve quickly realized these weren’t the kind of women she could recruit as clients for her accounting firm, as she had initially hoped. They were clearly connected to Matteo’s other, less visible family ventures.

The group chatted about upcoming social events—the renowned Spring Gala, elegant tea parties, exclusive luncheons, and the coveted annual Italian soirée. Genevieve sipped her sweet tea quietly, trying to ignore the heat radiating from Matteo’s stare. She smiled and nodded along, pretending to be fully aware of the darker, hidden aspects of her boss’s life.

As the conversation shifted toward the latest fashion trends, Genevieve searched for a way to slip away. She glanced down at her own modest sundress, a far cry from the designer gowns worn by the women around her. She had found it in a thrift store bin marked half-off. It fit her well, but it was nothing compared to the hundreds or thousands of dollars the other women’s outfits must have cost.

Finally, she gave in to the magnetic pull and cast a quick glance toward Matteo. Their eyes locked, and his gaze sharpened. Though he stood at the far end of the room, she stifled a gasp at the sight of him. He wore a slim grey pinstripe suit paired with a crisp white shirt and a floral tie. She noticed her own dress bore a pattern of soft pink roses, matching the flowers on his tie. When she looked back up, he raised his glass to his lips and winked.

“Uh oh, here comes trouble,” one of the women joked, pulling Genevieve’s attention away from Matteo.

She turned toward where the women were looking and felt her cheeks flush as Paul strolled toward them. She had only ever seen him in a suit three times before—at his uncle’s funeral and the two proms they had attended together. Now, as a fully grown man, he cut an impressive figure in his navy blue suit and cornflower blue tie. His eyes locked on her as he closed the distance, flashing that dazzling smile that used to make her knees weak.

Genevieve wondered if he was still hurting from the fight the night before. It hadn’t taken much to deduce how Matteo had bloodied his knuckles. Yet, looking at Paul now, his own knuckles were unmarked, and there was no bruising on his face. The only sign of injury was the slight hitch in his right leg as he walked.

“Hello, ladies. I thought we were here to watch a horse race, not host a fashion show,” Paul said as he stepped into their circle. “Then again, I’m not one to complain about a change in headliner.”

Laughter bubbled up from the women, who fanned themselves dramatically. “Oh, Paul, you’re too much,” the eldest among them said, her eyes openly admiring him.

“Only for you, Claudette,” he replied with a wink, causing her to giggle. “Have you all placed your bets yet?”

A soft murmur was their answer. They’d just been complaining about how their men refused to let them bet with their own money.

“I have,” Genevieve said, raising her hand slightly. The women shot her envious looks.

Paul’s baby blue eyes locked onto her with laser focus. His eyelids drooped slightly as if trying to hide the effect she had on him.

They always did when he was seconds away from kissing her.

She blinked away the flood of memories.

“Who did you bet on?” Maisy asked, sipping her lemonade.

“Royal Commander,” Genevieve announced, and most of the women nodded approvingly.

Paul’s smile turned sly, almost predatory. “Come on, Gen, I know you better than that. I thought you always went for the underdog?”

Maisy tilted her head, pointing a finger between the two men. “You two know each other?”

“We were high school sweethearts, weren’t we, Gen?” Paul reminded her.

Genevieve forced a tight smile. “I used to root for the underdog. Then I realized I’d rather bet on a sure thing.”

Paul’s grin faltered for just a moment. “But if Taming the Shrew wins, you’d triple your earnings.”

“I’m not interested in betting on hope. I’d rather put my money on the one who’s proven himself time and again and won’t let me down in the end.”

Paul’s smile wavered as he caught the double meaning in her words.

“Isn’t Taming the Shrew a mare?” one of the women asked.

“Well, just know that Royal Commander isn’t exactly what he seems, Gen,” Paul warned.

Genevieve narrowed her eyes, the women watching their exchange with growing curiosity. “I’m fully aware of Royal Commander’s other ventures off the track. But I don’t see how that concerns you.”

“Gen… maybe we could talk in private. Have dinner with me tonight, and I’ll explain,” Paul suggested, as if unaware of their audience.

Genevieve felt Matteo’s gaze tighten, the hairs on the back of her neck standing on end as her heart rate quickened. The scent of him filled her senses, and moments later, his hand settled possessively on her waist. Paul’s eyes flickered with a flash of jealousy before he masked it with a friendly smile aimed at Matteo.

“Mr. Accardi, nice to see you again,” Paul said with more enthusiasm than necessary.

Matteo squeezed Genevieve’s waist and gave Paul a curt nod, raising his glass to his lips. “Nice to see you too, Paul. How’s the stomach feeling this morning?”

Paul’s face lost some color, and Genevieve glanced at his flat abdomen.

“It’s fine, thank you for your help last night. Genevieve, can I have a word?”

“The race is about to start, Mr. Brooks. I thought the ladies might want to take their seats?” someone suggested, glancing at the women who gawked at the mafia don staking his claim.

“Right.” “Yes.” “Of course.” The women all murmured in agreement, scattering like startled mice.

“Genevieve, please,” Paul said earnestly.

She looked up at Matteo, who was now glaring at Paul. “Yeah, sure, but let’s make it quick.”

Matteo’s hand throbbed against her waist as he pivoted, blocking her view of Paul. His jaw twitched, and he shook his head once.

“I’ll be okay,” she reassured him. “Just a quick talk, and then I’ll meet you at the race.”

Matteo leaned in, whispering in her ear, “Our private box is down the hall through the door on the right. You better be there before the race starts. If you’re not, I’ll do worse than beat him up again. And remember, if he touches you—”

“Gen?” Paul interrupted, extending the very hand Matteo had been ready to threaten.

Genevieve looked up at Matteo as he leaned back and released her waist.

“You can walk with me and show me to our box,” she suggested to Paul.

Matteo’s glare burned hotter, but Paul’s smile stretched from ear to ear. She sidestepped his outstretched hand and headed for the door. Before she could open it herself, Paul was there, holding it open. Genevieve glanced back one last time at the furious Don before the door swung shut.

Once in the hallway, Paul took her hand gently and led her past the door to Matteo’s private box, then into a nearby supply closet. The sharp scent of cleaner filled the air.

“Genevieve, I don’t know if you fully realize what you’ve gotten yourself into,” Paul began without hesitation.

Genevieve sighed deeply. “Paul, I do know. I know exactly what Mr. Accardi is involved in, but I’m not part of that.”

Paul laughed, a bitter sound. “You really think you can pick and choose? You’re fooling yourself.”

“Accardi Industries is the first multi-million dollar client my firm has had. We were on the verge of bankruptcy. I didn’t have a choice.”

His eyes brightened slightly, hope flickering within them. “So, you’re only with him because…”

“I’m not with him,” she cut in defensively.

His hand brushed her forearm gently. “Then have dinner with me,” he urged.

Genevieve rubbed her temples, weary. “If I have dinner with you, will you leave me alone?”

Paul nodded eagerly. “Of course. If that’s what you want. I just want to catch up. Reconnect.”

The race was about to start in a few minutes. “Pick me up at the hotel at seven. It’s just dinner, Paul.”

His smile faltered briefly before he waved it off dismissively. “We’ll see where the night takes us.” His phone rang, and he sighed as he looked down at the caller ID. “I’ve got to go.”

Genevieve watched him leave, her heart heavy with unresolved feelings as the speakers crackled to life, announcing the start of the race. Just dinner, she reminded herself. Nothing more.